💡 Ice Maker Buying Guide
➡️ Check out these 10 bestseller ice makers that we hand picked and selected for your convenience:
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Type & Placement
When choosing an ice maker, the first thing to think about is where you’ll actually use it. Countertop or portable ice makers are compact and super convenient — you just fill them with water, plug them in, and let them work. They’re perfect for apartments, small kitchens, or even RV trips. Freestanding units are larger and can produce a much higher volume of ice, ideal if you entertain often or want something for a home bar setup. Built-in or undercounter models blend seamlessly into your cabinetry for that high-end, integrated look, though they typically require a water line and drainage. In short, match the type of ice maker to your available space and how often you’ll need ice.
Ice Production & Storage Capacity
Once you know the type, it’s time to think about how much ice you actually need. Every machine lists two important numbers — how much ice it can make in a day and how much it can store in its bin. Smaller countertop units usually make around 20 to 30 pounds of ice per day, which is plenty for daily use or small gatherings. But if you host parties, fill coolers, or run a home bar, you’ll want something that can handle 40 pounds or more. The storage size matters, too — having a large bin means you won’t need to empty it constantly when guests are over.
Ice Shape & Type
Not all ice is created equal, and the shape can actually change your whole experience. Standard cubes are the classic option that melt slowly and work well for just about any drink. Bullet-shaped ice is hollow and soft, perfect for quick-chilling water bottles or sodas. Nugget or pebble ice is a favorite for people who love to chew ice or make smoothies — it’s soft, airy, and melts evenly. If you’re after something a bit more premium, gourmet or crescent ice has that clear, professional look that elevates cocktails and melts more slowly, keeping drinks cold without watering them down.
Installation Requirements & Water/Drainage
Installation is something that can easily get overlooked, but it’s one of the most important details. Countertop machines are simple — just add water and plug them in. Freestanding and built-in models, however, often need a dedicated water line and drainage setup, so make sure you have access to plumbing before buying. It’s also a good idea to leave some room for ventilation and cleaning access, since ice makers need airflow to stay efficient and easy to maintain. Taking a few measurements ahead of time can save a lot of hassle later.
Features & Extras to Consider
Modern ice makers come packed with features that make life easier. Many have automatic shut-off sensors that stop production when the bin is full, or self-cleaning functions that save time on maintenance. Some models also include built-in water filters for better-tasting, clearer ice. Energy-efficient units run quieter and consume less power, which is great for long-term use. And of course, the design matters too — stainless steel finishes look sleek in most kitchens and bars. Choosing a model with the right combination of convenience, performance, and style will make the difference between a basic appliance and one you actually love using.
Maintenance & Water Quality
Keeping your ice maker clean is key to getting great-tasting, crystal-clear ice. Over time, minerals can build up inside the machine, especially if you use tap water. Regular cleaning helps prevent that, and many models make it easy with built-in cleaning cycles. Using filtered or distilled water also makes a noticeable difference — not only in the clarity of your ice but in how fresh it tastes. If you’re not using the machine for a while, empty any leftover water so it doesn’t get stale. A few small habits can go a long way toward keeping your ice maker running like new.
Matching Your Usage & Budget
The best ice maker is the one that fits your lifestyle. If you only need ice occasionally or want something easy to move around, a portable countertop unit will get the job done without costing much. If you host parties, run a home bar, or want a built-in kitchen upgrade, investing in a freestanding or undercounter model is worth it. For outdoor setups or RVs, look for durable, compact options designed for travel. The goal is to find the right balance between price, performance, and practicality so you get the most out of your purchase.
Pre-Purchase Considerations
Before you make a final decision, take a minute to think about how you’ll actually use your new ice maker day to day. Consider where it will go, how much ice you’ll need, and what type of ice you prefer for your drinks. Decide whether you want something that connects to a water line or one you can fill manually. Think about noise level, cleaning ease, and appearance if it’s going to sit out on display. Once you’ve figured out those details, choosing the right model becomes much simpler — and you’ll end up with an ice maker that truly fits your needs.
Check out more of our top rated recommended products in our APPLIANCES category
